Archives quotidiennes :

Joining Decision-Making, Moral Thinking, and Collective Action: Grand Challenges as a Phenomenology of Deliberation

Alfredo Grattarola, Jean-Pascal Gond & Stefan Haefliger (2026)

Journal of Management Studies. Online first, open access

Abstract. This conceptual article argues that the mutual relevance of grand challenges and organization and management studies is best approached phenomenologically. Rather than constituting objects to be theorized or denoting special empirical contexts, grand challenges structure researchers’ attention and shape their interpretations of the processes and systems of deliberation through which collective action is coordinated. From this perspective, grand challenges require researchers to innovate their understandings of deliberation and to ensure that newly generated knowledge is redirected towards management and policymaking. The article integrates the Carnegie School theory of organization with French pragmatic sociology’s theory of justification, or economies of worth, to develop a phenomenological model of situated deliberation that links decision-making with moral reasoning. This model highlights deliberation’s articulated, evaluative, contestable, and trans-institutional character, as well as its grounding in the cognitive capacities and sociality of actors and observers – regardless of the scale, scope, or stratification of the underlying coordination problems. Building on this framework, the article advocates that grand challenge researchers adopt the standpoint of entrepreneurial observers: actors anchored by socio-economic and scientific commitments who envision the integration of previously disjointed social systems of deliberation to orient collective action.

Extract: “Adopting the view that existing theories can contribute to the construction of novel framings of reality (Alvesson and Sandberg, 2024), this article approaches deliberation simultaneously through two classic theoretical traditions. The first is the Carnegie School theory of organization (CS), developed in Simon (1997), March and Simon (1993), Cyert and March (1963), and related works before and after these foundational texts. CS has been widely influential, both directly and through its impact on subsequent organizational theories (Anderson and Lemken, 2019; Bromiley et al., 2019; Gavetti et al., 2007).
The second is justification theory (JT), represented mainly in Boltanski and Thévenot (2006). JT is a cornerstone of French pragmatic sociology and the economics of conventions, two fields that emerged from a transdisciplinary movement attracting sociologists, economists, and other scholars from the 1980s onwards (Diaz-Bone and Larquier, 2022a; Jagd, 2011; Wilkinson, 1997). Beyond Boltanski and Thévenot’s economies of worth framework, this article also draws on concepts from these fields and from a growing body of JT-informed organization, management, and business studies (Cloutier et al., 2025; Grattarola et al., 2024).
The joint mobilization of CS and JT is warranted in terms of theoretical proximity, compatibility (Okhuysen and Bonardi, 2011), and complementarity. Both theories recognize a phenomenological dimension in action and socio-economic coordination (Frère and Jaster, 2019; Weick, 2019): actors address relevant problems by constructing representations of their circumstances that combine factual and normative elements. Reasoned approaches to socio-economic problems are grounded in such situated constructions, rather than in universally valid models or criteria. As March and Simon (1993) note, ‘from a phenomenological viewpoint, we can only speak of rationality relative to a frame of reference’ (p. 159). This applies equally to actors and to observers assessing their procedures, including scientists, who are granted neither superior rationality nor special critical faculties. Even in everyday situations, actors formulate judgments and critiques that ‘translate states of mind that act like scientific inquiries’ (Frère and Jaster, 2019, p. 148).
In both perspectives, frames of reference are products of social processes (Koumakhov, 2025). Complementarily, CS acknowledges the function for decision-making of social norms and moral evaluations that represent the focus of JT, while JT draws from CS key notions such as bounded rationality and composite organizational systems that extend decision-making over space and time (Favereau, 1989a; Koumakhov, 2009, 2025; Simon, 1952). Yet each theory emphasizes different aspects of cognition and organization, thus jointly offering an articulated conceptual toolkit for approaching deliberation along processual and structural dimensions. To anticipate key elements, CS focuses on how actors equipped with bounded rationality search for actionable options among which to realize a choice; in organizations, this process is orchestrated through organizational programs. JT, in turn, emphasizes how actors make situated judgments about the normative constraints of action, exercising critical capacity and coordinating through emergent conventions. Integrating CS and JT therefore enables a unified account of how situated actors construct coordination problems rationally and critically and extend coordination across spatial and temporal scales, and how observers, in turn, build higher-order representations of these constructions.” (p. 6/7)

Lien / Link