
Timothy Kuhn (2024)
Bristol: Bristol University Press
About the book. Corporate purpose’ has become a battleground for stakeholders’ competing desires. Some argue that corporations must simply generate profit; others suggest that we must make them create social change.
Leading organization studies scholar Timothy Kuhn argues that this ‘either/or’ thinking dramatically oversimplifies matters: today’s corporations must be many things, all at once.
Kuhn offers a bold new Communicative Theory of the Firm to highlight the authority that creates corporations’ identities and activities. The theory provides a roadmap for navigating that battleground of competing desires to produce more responsive corporations.
Drawing on communicative and new materialist theorizing, along with three insightful case studies, this book thoroughly redefines our understandings of what corporations are ‘for’.”
Extract: “Orders of worth in entrepreneurship
Prior to the work […] on shifts in the ‘spirit’ of capitalism, French sociologist Luc Boltanski and economist Laurent Thévenot puzzled over why logics of practice differ so dramatically across situational and institutional divides. In On Justification: Economies of Worth (1991/ 2006), they traced six distinct orders (or economies) of worth: inspired, domestic, fame, civic, market, and industrial, each of which include contrasting criteria for evaluations of quality with respect to objects, practices, persons, conceptions of the common good, and forms of reason. (Thévenot et al [2000] later added a ‘green’ economic order that addressed the valuing of nature as a social good and mode of reasoning; these are depicted in Table 6.1.) Boltanski and Thévenot acknowledge that these ‘worlds’ do not mark distinct social spheres, but instead cut across social life, affecting all practices and persons (see Thévenot, 2001). For instance, a decision about a firm’s potential promotional partner might assess the partner’s notoriety (fame), passion (inspired), or reliability (domestic). It might also assess the cost of the partnership (market) or the specialized knowledge to be gained from the collaboration (industrial). Multiple evaluative principles shape practice, and those that become explicit post hoc justifications for action provide insight into the claims to legitimacy made on behalf of the firm (Patriotta et al, 2011). The conceptual connections with the CTF’s vision of firms as authority machines is perhaps obvious. Boltanski and Thévenot’s work comprises a theory of value, and the promises of value written into the authoritative text necessarily reference some guiding logic(s) for such promises to have purchase; their work thus provides a vocabulary for understanding those logics. And the case is the same for claims to property, the other branch of the authoritative text: legal assertions of property rights might refer to a civic world, declarations of hierarchical role responsibility could draw upon an industrial order, and avowals of environmental responsibility would likely connect with both a market and a green world. Orders of worth, in other words, provide the ground from which promises of value and claims to property – the fundaments of authority – are built, asserting an everpresent ontological multiplicity into the conversation. Table 6.1 overviews the multiple elements of their scheme. It’s important to recognize that, while the columns and rows make it appear that this is a scheme comprised of mutually exclusive categorizations, Boltanski and Thévenot make it clear that any single statement or action (or, I’d add, firm) is likely to be the product of several intersecting justificatory resources at once.” (p. 147)
OpenEdition vous propose de citer ce billet de la manière suivante :
GdL (23 septembre 2024). What Do Corporations Want? Communicative Capitalism, Corporate Purpose, and a New Theory of the Firm. Économie des conventions. Consulté le 12 novembre 2026 à l’adresse https://doi.org/10.58079/12c60