Rune Sakslind, Roger Hestholm & Ove Skarpenes (2026)
Oslo: Scandinavian University Press. Open access

Abstract. When the achievements of the social sciences are described, they are often treated as the results of the endeavor of solitary researchers. But the agency in this process is not only an individual researcher, but the community of scientists. An important but often ignored element in this society is the quality of the communication between its members. We have observed a gap in this field in terms of critical judgment and evaluation of the results coming from independent projects, particularly when they pursue divergent research approaches in the study of similar topics. In this book, we attempt to clarify such controversies and contribute to their solution or dissolution. By reviewing, reconstructing, and extending the essential literature on the subject, we propose a framework for the study of such controversies and apply it to a case of disagreement in Norway. We examine the theoretical and methodological elements at work in this meeting of specific, situated research practices to demonstrate the need for, and the possibility of, heightened methodological reflection and innovation to improve scientific communication.