Archives mensuelles : août 2026

From Common Humanity to Sentient Commonality: Pragmatic Sociology and the Moral Worth of Nonhuman Animals

Tomi Lehtimäki (2026)

European Journal of Social Theory. Online first, open access.

Abstract. This article critically examines French pragmatic sociology and how it can operate as an analytical framework for understanding human–animal relations. While pragmatic sociology specifically accounts for nonhuman elements, it grounds its approach in the notion of common humanity, which excludes nonhuman animals. After identifying this tension, the article contrasts common humanity to the critique animal rights theorizing has directed at such humanistic starting points. This alternative form of commonality, promoted by animal rights, is based on sentience. Instead of focusing on various nonhumans in general, commonality based on sentience focuses on the shared capacities between humans and nonhuman animals. Following this, the article examines how the boundaries of such sentient commonality are demarcated and how sentience could operate in situational justifications. The article concludes that pragmatic sociology holds the potential to work as a promising analytical framework for analyzing human–animal relations if it can account for this new form of commonality.

Lien / Link

When numbers clash: mapping valuation and quantification controversies with digital methods

Umut Yener Kara & Burcu Şimşek (2026)

Quality and Quantity. Online first, pp. 1-23.

Abstract. This article argues for a methodological extension of digital controversy analysis to digital metrics by presenting a case study of user reviews for The Last of Us Part II on Metacritic. While digital controversy analysis is generally used to study public debates on science and technology, we contend that it can be naturally adapted to study controversial cases of evaluation and quantification for a more nuanced understanding of how users evaluate and quantify their judgments at the interface of digital evaluative infrastructures. To demonstrate our approach, we collected user reviews of The Last of Us Part II on Metacritic and analyzed them using a combination of sentiment analysis, semantic network analysis and thematic analysis. We found that most users adopted competitive and dichotomous evaluation practices, affectively polarized around issues related to politics and fandom. In this context, they frequently chose extreme scores with the intention of “balancing” the average score, a practice that we contend is deeply intertwined with Metacritic’s evaluation infrastructure and culture. In the controversy, numerical ratings not only served as one topic of the controversy but also served as the primary means through which the controversy was enacted. In this regard, our methodological approach allowed us to capture a sym-metrical dimension between qualitative judgements and quantitative ratings.

Lien / Link

Cocoa, self-exhaustion and social, economic, and environmental recomposition in Ghana

Gary Herrigel & Patrick Feuerstein (2026)

Review of Social Economy. pp. 1-40.

Abstract. This paper deals with a specific case in the contemporary crisis of globalization. It examines the way in which rules, roles, and conventions governing cocoa production in Ghana have evolved over time. Using a theoretical approach to global exchange rooted in the economy of conventions, economic anthropology, and pragmatism-inspired economic sociology, the paper views exchange as a form of social cooperation that requires rules and conventions to make it possible. We show that the specific arrangements that have evolved in the cocoa industry in Ghana appear today to be self-undermining. As older strategies exhaust themselves, neither incumbent practices nor any feature of contending alternative strategies for organizing global cocoa exchange represent an obvious ‘most efficient’ option for producers. The market is not going to decide how Ghana manages the reality of its exhausted cocoa industry. Only extra-economic deliberation and struggle over lines of specialization and cooperation in exchange will.

Lien / Link

Food and Convention Theory

Rainer Diaz-Bone (2026)

In Rainer Diaz-Bone & Guillemette de Larquier (eds.), Handbook of economics and sociology of conventions. Cham: Springer, Online first

Abstract. Economics and sociology of conventions (in short EC/SC or convention theory) has a huge body of research on food and agriculture. The chapter presents the beginning of this research field and its importance for the interdisciplinary and international establishment of EC/SC since the early 1990s. EC/SC has delivered the foundations for studies in disciplines such as economic geography, economic sociology, or institutional analysis applied to food and agricultural analysis. EC/SC’s most important theoretical models developed by Michael Storper and Robert Salais (worlds of production), Luc Boltanski and Laurent Thévenot (orders of worth and quality conventions), or Boltanski and Arnaud Esquerre (enrichment economy) are widely employed in this research field. The chapter focuses on seminal research on cheese (camembert), coffee, and wine. Thereby the role of conventions for the social construction of food quality and food categories is presented. A main aim of the chapter is to introduce the principal concepts of EC/SC to demonstrate its huge range of existing and possible applications in the analysis of food, food-related practices, and structures of food markets and food branches. EC/SC links the analysis of food production, food distribution, and food consumption with the analysis of food evaluation and valorization. For this, EC/SC’s research on eating out and restaurants is of importance, because it completes the production perspective with a stronger emphasis on institutions for the consumption of food.

Lien / Link

Bio-Cultural Diversity and Good Food Conventions: Comparing Engaged Eaters in Germany, Italy and Norway

Stefan Wahlen, Bärbel Mahr, Gunnar Vittersø, Hanne Torjusen, Mattia Andreola & Sabina Kuraj (2026)

International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food, 32(1), pp. 283-300. Open access.

Abstract. This paper examines how highly invested food consumers in in Italy, Germany and Norway navigate the tensions between cultural food traditions and environmental sustainability. Drawing on French conventions theory and focus group discussions, we examine how these consumers justify their food choices in light of biocultural diversity – understood as the interplay between food traditions, ecological concerns, and the use of natural resources. Our analysis reveals three primary justification frameworks, or ‘worlds of worth’: the Domestic World, which is grounded in tradition and trust-based relationships with producers; the Green World, which focuses on ecological responsibility; and the Inspired World, which prioritises creativity and personal fulfilment. While these worlds often coexist in everyday food practices, they also generate conflicts, for example between ethical ideals and convenience, or sustainability and cultural heritage. Italian participants in our study emphasised domestic and convivial food traditions, Germans expressed a strong commitment to creative and waste-conscious eating, and Norwegians balanced ecological awareness with self-sufficiency and national food identity. Our findings demonstrate that food choices are not shaped by fixed national cultures, but by context-dependent justifications reflecting multiple, and sometimes conflicting, values. We conclude by emphasising the importance of acknowledging these tensions in order to better integrate cultural and environmental priorities in sustainable food systems.

Extract: “This paper explores the connections between eating culturally specific foods and the natural world. A particular focus is on how engaged eaters justify their food at critical moments in the relationship between cultural conventions and natural resources. We draw on the work of Boltanski and Thévenot (2006/1991) to examine critical moments of justification, or the ’conventions’ that shape social interactions, economic institutions and the governance of food systems. Their theory of  conventions provides a valuable analytical framework for studying the complex and ever-changing relationships between social norms, cultural values, economic practices, and the use of natural resources within food systems (Ponte 2016). It allows for an examination of the relationship between cultural norms related to ’good food’ and the broader issue of biodiversity and natural resource use. The theory is also relevant for understanding how conventions evolve over time, leading to different modes of coordination between food chain actors and collective expectations about food quality. We analyse data from focus groups with engaged eaters involved in food initiatives, to compare the cultural conventions of eating in Italy, Norway and Germany, and how these engaged eaters reflect broader concerns about natural resources and biodiversity. This enables us to compare tensions and conflicts in consumer conventions around ‘good food’, and to explore how these conventions shape and are shaped by the biological realities of food production. For example, while traditional meals in many European countries are culturally specific and often centred around meat, recent dietary trends such as the Planetary Health Diet challenge these conventions by promoting plant-based diets. Such changes in dietary habits may also be reflected in a shift towards increased cultivation of vegetables and legumes as alternative sources of proteins.” (p. 284)

Lien / Link

The Sociology of Critique. Towards a Grammatical Approach to Social Action

Manuel Cervera-Marzal & Bruno Frère (2026)

Sociology Lens, pp. 1-11

Abstract. This study is concerned with the notion of “grammar” as it was developed at the core of Luc Boltanski and Laurent Thévenot’s pragmatic sociology. This notion is particularly useful for articulating the normative elements that motivate and justify social action. But a specific case—that of the civil disobedience—has led us to identify an epistemological difficulty that this paradigm cannot successfully resolve in its current state. This case raises a broader question: how can we understand the fact that the common goods invoked by actors to justify their actions do not always correspond to the characteristics of the actions that sociologists are able to observe? To achieve this resolution, and thus, to reverse our fieldwork out of the theoretical impasse into which pragmatic sociology risks driving it, we suggest that the paradigm’s concept of grammar should be modified by drawing on Noam Chomsky’s concept of generative grammar and Ludwig Wittgenstein’s reflections on rules and language games.

Lien / Link

Se passer ou pas des néonicotinoïdes ?

To use or not to use neonicotinoids? An analysis of disputes over their use by beet growers based on modes of action

Claude Compagnone (2026)

Revue d’éthique et de théologie morale, 332(2), pp. 31-47

Résumé. Cet article vise à s’interroger sur la manière dont, aujourd’hui en France, les discours et les actions se structurent dans l’espace public national autour de l’usage des néonicotinoïdes par les producteurs de betterave. S’appuyant sur les régimes d’actions « tactique-stratégique » et « de la justification », il montre comment des coups et contrecoups se succèdent dans le temps, depuis plus d’une vingtaine d’années, entre les défenseurs et les contempteurs de cet usage, et comment les uns et les autres se réfèrent, pour ce faire, à des principes supérieurs communs différents. Les événements décrits tiennent plus de la guerre larvée, avec une succession d’opérations tactiques et de moments de paix armée, et rendent compte d’une certaine incapacité politique à établir des compromis à même de permettre la construction d’une autre réalité.

Abstract. This article sets out to examine current French discourse and actions in the national public sphere concerning the use of neonicotinoids by beet producers. Drawing on the “tactical-strategic” and “justification” approaches, we narrate more than twenty years of debate between defenders and detractors of this practice, showing how both sides rely on different foundational principles. The events described herein resemble a sort of low-intensity war, with a succession of tactical operations and periods of armed peace, and reflect a certain political inability to reach compromises that would enable the construction of a different reality.

Lien / Link

‘€100 million was inevitable’ – football fans as co-creators of market values in professional football

Jürgen Beyer (2026)

European Journal for Sport and Society, Online first, open access, pp. 1-20.

Abstract. This article examines how the online fan community on the German platform transfermarkt.de co-constructs the market values of professional footballers. Through a qualitative text analysis of 1030 forum posts, the study identifies six central justificatory conventions: performance, comparison, market, speculation, reputation, and intangible value. Fans’ arguments encompass assessments of sporting performance, statistical data and comparisons with peers, current transfer offers, speculative projections, club-specific contributions, and considerations of public reputation. Market values thus arise as dynamic and collectively negotiated constructs, reflecting multiple, sometimes conflicting, norms of evaluation. The findings demonstrate that fans are not passive observers but active participants who shape the criteria and legitimacy of market values. In doing so, they contribute both to the ongoing economisation of professional football and to the social legitimation of market value as a key category within the sport.

Lien / Link

Weisheit der Laien – Die Rechtfertigungsordnungen von Fußballfans bei der Bestimmung von Marktwerten

Wisdom of Laypeople: The Orders of Justification Used by Football Fans in the Determination of Market Values

Jürgen Beyer (2026)

Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie. Online first, open access, pp. 1-28

Zusammenfassung. Die auf Basis der „Wisdom-of-the-crowd“-Logik bestimmten Marktwerte von Fußballern der Online-Plattform „Transfermarkt.de“ werden in Medienberichten, in der Klubpraxis sowie in der wissenschaftlichen Forschung als anerkannter Referenzwert verwendet. In diesem Beitrag wird untersucht, wie Fußballfans auf dieser Plattform Marktwerte diskutieren und Auf- und Abwertungsvorschläge rechtfertigen. Mittels einer qualitativen Inhaltsanalyse von 1030 Beiträgen aus dem Forum „Marktwert-Analyse“ werden die Argumentationsmuster untersucht, mit denen die Fans ihre Vorstellungen von angemessenen Marktwerten begründen und legitimieren. Die Ergebnisse zeigen, dass sechs zentrale Rechtfertigungsordnungen den Bewertungsdiskurs strukturieren: Leistungskonvention, Vergleichskonvention, Marktkonvention, Spekulationskonvention, Reputationskonvention und Ertragskonvention. Die vertretenen Argumentationsmuster reichen von der Bewertung sportlicher Leistungen und statistischer Kennzahlen über Vergleiche mit anderen Spielern und Transfermarktangeboten bis hin zu Annahmen über zukünftige Entwicklungen, der Akzentuierung des spezifischen Werts für den Verein sowie der Bewertung der öffentlichen Anerkennung von Spielern. Die letztlich von der Online-Plattform festgelegten Marktwerte der Spieler entstehen als Ergebnis fortlaufender, kollektiv ausgehandelter Debatten. Die Ergebnisse unterstreichen, dass der aus dem Bezug auf unterschiedliche Bewertungskonventionen entstehende Dissens die Weisheit der Laien stützt, da so fortlaufend neue Anlässe für Bewertungen geschaffen werden.

Abstract. Player market values generated on the online platform transfermarkt.de are based on a ‘wisdom of the crowd’ logic and are used as an established point of reference in media reports, by football clubs, and in academic research. This article examines how football fans on this platform discuss player market values and justify proposals for upward or downward adjustments. Drawing on a qualitative content analysis of 1030 forum posts from the market value analysis thread, the study analyses the argumentative patterns through which fans substantiate and legitimise their notions of appropriate market values. The findings reveal six key justifications that structure the valuation discourse: performance, comparison, market, speculation, reputation, and club benefit. These argumentative patterns range from assessments of athletic performance and statistical indicators to comparisons with other players, transfer market activity, and assumptions about future developments. They also include an emphasis on a player’s specific value to the club and evaluations of public recognition. Ultimately, the market values are determined as the outcome of ongoing, collectively negotiated debates. The results underscore that the dissent arising from the reference to different valuation conventions supports the wisdom of laypeople, as this continuously creates new opportunities for valuations.

Lien / Link

Ecological work: Insights from reuse and repair activities in France

Géraldine Rieucau, Annie Jolivet, Jennifer Laussu & Phiippe Légé (2026)

Environmental Science & Policy, 183, 104454.

Abstract. This study examines the characteristics of ecological work in the French reuse and repair sector, which is part of the Social and Solidarity Economy (SSE). We consider workers as actors in the ecological transition and argue that a micro-level approach is relevant to understanding the logic of the reuse and repair sector. Empirical data (37 interviews with workers and 8 non-participant observations) were collected in 2022–2024 at a reuse and repair centre in a rural area 100 km from Paris, France, involving workers from partner organisations engaged in this activity and representatives of the SSE reuse and repair sector. We propose an original theoretical approach based on the economics and sociology of conventions combining literature and concepts about environmental issues on the one hand, and from analysis of organisation, work and employment on the other, and designed to investigate ecological work. The workplace could provide the opportunity to reveal, through a diversity of reality tests, an attachment to the nature. We explore the ecological arguments mobilized by workers when evaluating materials, navigating institutional devices, interacting with colleagues and partners, innovating, and demonstrating environmental commitment. Our results indicate that while ecological work is rooted in the domestic, civic, and industrial polities, it simultaneously transcends these traditional logics. The justifications are poorly consistent with the market logic. The compromise identified within the organisation aligns with the green compromise that underpins the functioning of the reuse and repair system. However, such a green compromise may be under-equipped to withstand increasing market logic.

Lien / Link